Peer Review Process

Peer Review Policy

Bioactive Journal is committed to maintaining the quality, originality, and academic integrity of published research through a fair, objective, and systematic peer review process. Every manuscript submitted to the journal is evaluated to determine its relevance, scientific contribution, methodological soundness, and suitability for publication.

The journal applies a double-blind peer review system, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential throughout the evaluation process. Editorial decisions are made independently and are based on the scientific merit of each submission.

1. Manuscript Evaluation and Editorial Screening

Upon submission, the editorial team conducts an initial assessment to ensure that the manuscript meets the journal's submission requirements.

The preliminary evaluation includes:

  • Scope and Relevance — determining whether the manuscript aligns with the aims and scope of Bioactive Journal

  • Submission Requirements — checking manuscript structure, completeness, formatting, and supporting documents

  • Originality Assessment — examining the manuscript for potential plagiarism and inappropriate text overlap using available similarity-checking tools

  • Research Ethics — assessing whether relevant ethical considerations and approvals have been adequately addressed

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or declined before entering the peer review stage.

2. Reviewer Assignment and Evaluation

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to qualified reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area of the submitted research.

Reviewer selection considers:

  • Academic qualifications and expertise relevant to the manuscript

  • Research experience and scholarly contributions in the relevant field

  • Independence and the absence of potential conflicts of interest

  • Ability to provide an objective and constructive scientific assessment

Reviewers are expected to evaluate the manuscript based on the following criteria:

  • Originality and significance of the research

  • Relevance to the journal's scope

  • Appropriateness of the research design and methodology

  • Accuracy and clarity of data presentation and interpretation

  • Quality of discussion and relevance of supporting literature

  • Compliance with applicable research ethics standards

  • Overall scientific contribution to the field

Reviewers provide comments and recommendations to assist the editor in reaching an informed editorial decision.

3. Review Standards and Reviewer Responsibilities

To maintain the integrity of the review process, reviewers are expected to:

  • Maintain Confidentiality — protect all manuscript information and refrain from sharing or using unpublished material for personal or professional purposes

  • Provide Constructive Feedback — deliver objective, evidence-based, and respectful comments that help authors improve their work

  • Declare Conflicts of Interest — inform the editorial team of any professional, financial, or personal relationships that may affect impartiality

  • Observe Ethical Standards — report suspected plagiarism, data manipulation, duplicate publication, or other potential research misconduct to the editor

  • Respect Review Integrity — conduct manuscript assessments independently and disclose any use of permitted digital or AI-assisted tools in accordance with the journal's applicable policies

Reviewers must not make editorial decisions or contact authors directly regarding the manuscript unless authorized by the editorial team.

4. Editorial Assessment and Decision

After considering the reviewers' reports, the editor evaluates the manuscript and determines the appropriate editorial decision.

The possible decisions include:

  • Accept — the manuscript is considered suitable for publication without further substantive revision

  • Minor Revision — limited corrections or clarifications are required before acceptance can be considered

  • Major Revision — substantial improvements are necessary, and the revised manuscript may undergo further evaluation

  • Reject — the manuscript does not meet the journal's scientific, ethical, or editorial requirements

The final decision rests with the editor and is not determined solely by reviewer recommendations. The editor may request additional assessments when necessary to ensure fairness and consistency.

5. Manuscript Revision and Reassessment

Authors receiving a revision decision are required to address the reviewers' and editor's comments carefully.

Authors should:

  • Submit a revised version of the manuscript

  • Provide a point-by-point response explaining how each comment has been addressed

  • Clearly indicate substantial changes made to the manuscript

  • Provide scientific justification when a suggested revision is not adopted

Revised manuscripts are assessed by the editor and may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation. The editorial team will communicate the next decision to the corresponding author.

6. Publication Ethics and Research Integrity

Bioactive Journal upholds ethical standards throughout the publication process. Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to act responsibly and transparently.

The journal does not tolerate:

  • Plagiarism and self-plagiarism

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data

  • Duplicate or redundant publication

  • Improper authorship practices, including gift and ghost authorship

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest

  • Manipulation of the peer review process

Authors are responsible for ensuring that all individuals listed as authors have made appropriate scholarly contributions and have approved the submitted manuscript.

The use of artificial intelligence or AI-assisted technologies must be disclosed when required by the journal's applicable policies. Such technologies must not replace the authors' responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their work.

Allegations of publication misconduct will be assessed by the editorial team in accordance with established publication ethics principles and relevant journal policies. Corrective actions may include rejection, correction, retraction, or other appropriate measures.

7. Editorial Transparency and Post-Publication Integrity

Bioactive Journal recognizes that publication quality requires continued attention even after an article has been published.

The journal may take appropriate editorial action when significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication. Depending on the nature and severity of the issue, actions may include:

  • Publication of a correction or erratum

  • Publication of an expression of concern

  • Retraction of an article when justified by serious ethical or scientific concerns

Any post-publication action will be handled transparently and communicated through the journal's official publication platform.

Through this peer review framework, Bioactive Journal seeks to promote responsible scholarly communication, strengthen research quality, and maintain the trust of authors, reviewers, readers, and the wider academic community.